Game Information

Guns Dont Kill People - Videogames Do!


"Ban these evil games", "Videogame violence corrupting our nation's youth", "video games stole my husband". It seems everyday that the media are making more and more claims about the evils of videogames. But are these claims based on fact, or is it merely that there is a juicy new scapegoat out there that the woes of the world can be pinned on?

Many people will be aware of the Daily Mail's 'Manhunt' story by now. The paper ran with the first page headline of 'Ban these evil games', claiming that 17 year old Warren LeBlanc's obsession with the ultra-violent Rockstar game 'Manhunt' drove him to beat his 14 year old friend, Stefan Pakeerah, over 50 times with both a claw hammer and knife. The tabloid then proceeded to assert "the hammer-and-knife killing mirrored scenes in the ultra-violent game". The paper also ran a quote from the mother of the victim, saying that, despite the fact the game had an 18 certificate, "it's no good saying this game is marketed at adults. Everyone knows that young children get their hands on them."

But what was the real motive behind the murder, and the follow up story? It's easy to see where the motive for the Daily Mail's story came from. In the words of the panel of the IGDA (International Games Developers Association) "it was a slow news day". And what better to liven it up than blood, violence and a convenient scapegoat?

There are two other important facts to remember about this awful murder. Firstly, what do the police say? After the headline in the Daily Mail you may think that they came to the conclusion that it was the game that set Warren off on his murderous way. However the conclusion that the police arrived at is that the motive was robbery. It turns out that Warren Leblanc had, in actual fact, a Ł75 drugs fuelled debt to a local gang when he lured his erstwhile friend into the park that night, and originally intended merely to rob him. The police report makes no mention of 'Manhunt' whatsoever. This may be because the game was discovered in Stefan's room, rather than that of the killer. Both of these pertinent facts were absent from the Mail's front page the day this story ran.

And one must ask, how was it that Mrs. Pakeerah missed the fact her own 14 year old son owned this ultra-violent game, which he could only have acquired if an adult had purchased it for him.

"But is the game any good?" I hear you cry. Quite simply, no. 'Manhunt' is one of those games that are the key stumbling blocks in the path of truly adult games. Computer games are now reaching the point where mature themes, meaning detailed, involving stories that can deal with events in the real world, and portray realistic reactions to them, are becoming possible. Yet some developers insist on pouring out games that are aimed only at fuelling the testosterone driven adolescent fantasies of teenage sadists. When you consider tack like 'Manhunt' in the light of games like 'Half-Life 2', with its compelling narrative interwoven through beautiful, breathtaking scenery, you realise just how tawdry 'Manhunt' really is.

The consensus at the IGDA meeting this year was that the game was merely "a rubbish game with a layer of crunchy ultra-violence slapped on top". No doubt the loss of such a young child as Stefan Pakeerah was a tragedy in its own right, but the true tragedy here is twofold. Almost overnight the game, whose sales had been a mere trickle before, started flying off the shelves of those few shops who hadn't banned it, the concept of censorship lending the game a certain cachet. Even worse, in the words of Rob Fahey of the IGDA, is the way in which "the games industry 'close ranks' to defend it [Manhunt] when its an aberration compared to most games - do you see Stephen Spielberg defending hardcore porn films?"

There are many well-documented stories of the media blaming video games for the world's woes. They blame the twin-towers terrorist attack on Microsoft, who trained the pilots with their flight simulator software. They blame Doom for the shootings at Columbine High School, because the game where you openly flaunt weapons helped the boys secretively plan their murderous rampage. There is often claimed to be a direct link between the American sniper incident and videogames, because the target shooting skills of the sniper were developed from videogames, and nothing to do with the comprehensive rifle training he received from the US army. The simple truth is that it takes more than just games to transform ordinary people into murderers.

According to the tabloids we should currently be inundated by hordes of slavering, violence obsessed gamers. However as this plague has yet to develop maybe we should take what they are saying with a pinch of salt. When a game player unglues him (or her) self from the computer monitor and doesn't find a machine gun lying at their feet, the suspension of disbelief is broken. It takes planning and training to carry out acts like these. Saying that violent games turn people into killers is the same as saying that people exposed to Islam will become terrorists. There is no more violence in most games than there is in movies, or horror books. In fact even the U.S court of appeal wrote, "(the idea that) there is a strong likelihood that minors who play violent videogames will suffer a deleterious effect on their psychological health is simply not supported in record." In other words, videogames are not the cause of violence.

What this really comes down to is the parents, and the worldview that they impart onto their children. If the parents don't take the time to talk to their children explain to them right and wrong, then how will the child know what he or she should do? How many parents explain to their child that the game is not real; that in real life you can't do everything you can in the game? While violence sells it does not educate, and unfortunately in this day and age 'upbringing by Playstation' is becoming a more and more common phenomenon as parents' time constraints get the better of them.

All games have a strict rating system in place, called ESBN. This system is designed to prevent games from falling into the hands of minors, and yet often when a child is refused a game by the management the parent, even after the rating system has been explained to them, buys the game anyway. Parents need to be educated more about what they are buying, instead of buying whatever game the kids ask for; maybe they need to consider what they want their children to be seeing. Would you let a child of 12-14, or even younger, watch hardcore porn or an 18 rated movie? Then maybe you shouldn't let them play an 18 rated game. The stereotype that games are just for kids is badly out of date, and maybe it's time parents started to take more responsibility for what their children play on.

In every group there are a few who don't fit in with the social norm. Is it true that these people can be influenced by violent videogames? No doubt. But is this the root cause of their affliction? No. Books, movies, rough and tumble play; all of these blend reality and fiction. What people need to accept is that they must take responsibility for their own actions, and that maybe societies ills are rooted in larger problems than a small animated character shooting another small animated character.

Daniel Robson runs http://www.shock-therapy.org where he offers his own freeware, as well hosting freeware for Symbian UIQ 7.0 phones, especially the Sony Ericsson PX00 series.


MORE RESOURCES:

Macleans.ca

First non-game apps show PS Vita's wider potential
CNN International
By Kyle Orland, Ars Technica (Ars Technica) -- These days, it seems, it's not enough for a digital device to just play games. To keep up with the smartphones and tablet computers of the world, any game system needs to at least nod in the direction of ...
Top games for the PlayStation VitaSan Jose Mercury News (blog)
Mobile games locked in Mortal KombatMacleans.ca
Sony's Vita arrives just as market may be fadingReuters
San Francisco Chronicle -MarketWatch (press release)
all 1,294 news articles »


New York Daily News

'Hunger Games' advance tickets released
Entertainment Weekly
by Michelle Profis Hunger Games advance tickets went on sale this morning with just a month left to go until the film's March 23 release — and it's dominating Fandango, accounting for 83 percent of the site's total sales today.
'The Hunger Games' National Mall Tour will include stars Jennifer Lawrence ...New York Daily News
The Hunger Games Cast Embarking on National Mall TourUs Magazine
Review: 'Hunger Games' is insightful, entertaining readSan Jose Mercury News
Wired News (blog) -MTV.com
all 214 news articles »


USA TODAY

Linsanity live: Lin, Knicks host wounded Hawks
USA TODAY
By Ellen J. Horrow, USA TODAY The New York Knicks looks to rebound from Monday's loss to the New Jersey Nets, while the Atlanta Hawks will have to contend without the services of All-Star Joe Johnson in tonight's game at Madison Square Garden in New ...
In Miami, the Heat await a look at LinsanitySan Francisco Chronicle
Live: Lin, Knicks host wounded HawksTucson Citizen
Lin, Knicks aim to bounce back vs. HawksChicago Tribune
New York Times
all 7,101 news articles »


The Daily Star

Olyroos miss London Games with 1-0 loss
The Australian
Once again, Australia were toothless in attack and have the ignominious distinction of failing to score a goal after five group games. The loss left Australia bottom of their four-team group, trailing second placed Uzbekistan by five points with one ...
Aussies miss OlympicsSportal.com.au
Pressure on Australia to win two gamesgulfnews.com

all 66 news articles »


Chicago Tribune

Surgery For Calhoun; He'll Miss At Least Two More Games
Chicago Tribune
UConn will be missing coach Jim Calhoun for at least two more games. Calhoun, 69, will have a surgical procedure on Monday to relieve his spinal condition, which will keep him from coaching against Syracuse on Saturday night and at Providence next ...
Connecticut Coach Calhoun to Have Back Surgery, Will Miss Two More GamesBloomberg
UConn's Jim Calhoun to undergo surgery, miss two more gamesUSA TODAY (blog)
U-Conn.'s Calhoun to undergo surgery next week for lower back condition, will ...Washington Post

all 201 news articles »


USA TODAY

Bucks-Bulls Preview
USA TODAY
(Sports Network) - Reigning NBA MVP Derrick Rose recently made his return to the hardwood following a five-game absence due to lower back spasms. Rose and the Bulls will try to give the Central Division-rival Milwaukee Bucks a few spasms Wednesday, ...
Derrick Rose returns, leads Bulls past HawksBoston Herald
Hawks fall behind early to Bulls, lose for seventh time in past 10 gamesAtlanta Journal Constitution
Hawks-Bulls PreviewCBSSports.com

all 674 news articles »


Los Angeles Times

'You can't be OK with losing,' Clippers' Chris Paul says
Los Angeles Times
Paul says 'it's great' the Clippers are mad about losing a tough overtime game to the Spurs and a game to the Warriors, but they plan to make corrections and have strong showing against Nuggets. By Broderick Turner These are different times with the ...
What to watch: Clippers-NuggetsESPN (blog)
Utah Jazz shootaround — Raja Bell out vs. Timberwolves; Josh Howard likely to ...Salt Lake Tribune (blog)
Nuggets set for playoff push as season reaches midway pointNBA.com

all 449 news articles »


The Guardian

Miami Heat Increase Win-streak to Seven Games: Fan Reaction
Yahoo! Sports
Contributor Network 4 hours, 46 minutes ago The Miami Heat increased their current win streak to seven games on Feb. 21, defeating the Sacramento Kings 120-108 at the American Airlines Arena. The Heat struggled in the opening quarter of the game, ...
Wade, Heat streak to seven straight wins, down Kings 120-108Hamilton Spectator
Heat win seventh straightPhiladelphia Inquirer

all 623 news articles »


Don't Beware the Bobcats
Wall Street Journal (blog)
Their last attempt against Indiana, in game No. 31, didn't go so well: The Pacers won by 35 points. That's how it's gone for Charlotte in this abbreviated season with a decade's worth of pain. The Bobcats have lost 10 games by at least 20 points.

and more »


Sportsnet.ca

Day 12 — Doug Wilson: 'In the big picture, one or two games is not going to ...
San Jose Mercury News (blog)
A follow-up question asked Wilson if the team's current season-high,four-game winless streak and 1-4-1 road trip made it more or less likely he'd make a deal, but it didn't get a direct answer. “We're not playing up to our capabilities right now,” ...
Nash trade talk tough to hearTheChronicleHerald.ca
Do the Sharks have the final piece already in place?Yahoo! Sports

all 404 news articles »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006